Video Analytics Solutions Are Not All Created Equal
The use of video analytics is growing rapidly in the surveillance market. It has proven indispensable in high-risk security projects, and is becoming increasingly popular in commercial jobs for a wide range of applications, including outdoor protection, customer service measurements, people counting, crowd monitoring, and many others.
We are not far from the day when most video products will include embedded content analysis, making all video products smarter. However, there is a lack of solid technical information to help compare available technologies. The problem is that companies often make grand claims, but many fall far short in performance, leading to widespread disappointment.
The purpose of this article, therefore, is to outline the general principles of how video analytics works, in non-technical language, and examine how competing technologies try to solve these problems. The results vary dramatically, and a closer look shows why there are such big differences in performance.
Video analytics systems are built on three core components:
- Motion detection and object segmentation: This is where the video is processed to separate foreground objects from the background. This is the most processor intensive part of video analytics, accounting for up to 80% of the computational resources. However, there is a wide range in how well different products segment moving objects from the rest of the video.
- Object Tracking: This step tracks groups of pixels that are foreground objects as they move from frame to frame. If a group of pixels moves across the scene, it is probably a foreground object. The challenge is to track this blob of changing pixels. Once again, there is a huge range in performance from the different approaches taken.
- Object Classification: This function identifies the type of object detected. If a group of pixels moves across the scene, it is probably a foreground object. The challenge is to track this blob of changing pixels. Once again, there is a huge range in performance from the different approaches taken.
Systems vary in how well they perform each of these three steps. For example, there are many products being sold today as video analytics? that are better described as advanced video motion detection. They can extract blobs of pixels moving across a scene, but cannot tell whether these objects are people, vehicles or anything else. In other words, they have no object classification.
Such systems have a harder time distinguishing a branch blowing in the wind from a person, but some of them have added object size calibration to help ignore things that are too big or too small. Large animals and tree branches are still a problem with these technologies, and they also require someone manually calibrating each camera for object sizes. Advanced video motion detection systems might be able to perform all the behavior detection types you see in the best video analytics systems, such as tripwires, direction of travel, intrusion detection, etc., but their results cannot compare to the accuracy of systems with superior object classification.
This is just one example of where some products skimp to reduce the amount of processing required. The problem is that you can't easily tell the difference by just looking at such solutions or reading their literature. They claim to offer all of the same features you see in high end systems. However, the differences in results are stark.
Even the best of the advanced video motion detection systems are at least 10X worse compared to even the poorest true video analytics products. Extensive testing easily proves this out, but most integrators and users don't have the time to test dozens of products to find one that works.
For a more detailed description of how video analytics works, read All Analytics are not Created Equal? by Doug Marman, CTO and VP of Products at VideoIQ, at http://www.videoiq.net/products/resources.
Doug Marman is CTO and VP of Products at VideoIQ, makers of the ip camera with built-in intelligent video analytics.
Free Articles:
The Internet’s First How-To Video Blog About Search Marketing
Web Marketing Watch, a new daily video show online, gives visitors search and online marketing tutorials in easy-to-digest 3-7 minute visual spots.
Video Blogging Made Easy -- Professional Video Blog WordPress Theme Makes Inserting Videos on a Blog As Easy As 1-2-3
Tuesday, March 18th, 2008 will mark a truly historic moment in the history of video blogging. Beginning at 1pm on this day, Ben Cope, The Internet Genius, will release the Video Blog Dream Theme, a premium WordPress theme designed exclusively for video bloggers.
The Video Blog Dream Theme makes it easy for blog owners to insert videos on their site, without having the hassle or frustration of trying to copy and paste the HTML embed code.
DVDVideoSoft Releases Free Video Dub -- Free Lossless Video Editor
DVDVideoSoft -- an Internet resource dedicated to free software, multimedia software guides and tutorials -- has just released new video-editing software called Free Video Dub.
Birthday Video - Turn Your Childs Party Video Into A Fun Music Video
Kid Birthday Party - Birthday VideoMost people shoot some random video of their child's birthday party, then toss the video in a drawer and forget about it.Hey, we're talking about some precious video of an important event in your child's life.
Video the Tube - The Best Video Rant Contest Debuts; Free Video Upload Site will Award $1,000 for Best Video Rant
Each day millions of college students upload and share video content, however, both liberal and conservative video file sharers argue that their views are being suppressed by some of the major video sharing communities. Is there a solution? Well ask noted producer and author, John Fair. CampusRights.net launches Video The Tube - The Best Video Rant contest. Brand new interactive website that allows a student to upload and share their best video rant and win a chance at $1000 in cash.
Ski Racing Videos.com provides free video hosting for ski teams and racers
Ski Racing Videos.com provides free hosting of videos for ski teams, racers, coaches, parents, and fans. Easily upload and share videos that are solely about ski racing. Including training and racing videos from Slalom, GS, Super G, Downhill, and skiercross.
New Versions of Free Video Editing Software, Video Converters Available at DVDVideoSoft
DVDVideoSoft, an independent software vendor, announces the bulk update of its free video editing software. This site also provides a free video converter and multimedia software guides and tutorials.
Video Marketing: 3 Free Resources To Take Your Video Marketing Efforts To The Next Level
If you have been using videos to market your business or even considering doing it, this article will show you free resources available online that will allow you to quickly create more videos for your business and market them as well An estimated 90% of people would rather watch a video, than read
NewBlue Cartoonr Offers Free Cartoon Effect Plugin and Transforms Video into Animation for Free
High-end cartoon effects are no longer the exclusive domain of Hollywood big boys thanks to video effects plugin creator NewBlue, Inc. Now anyone using leading desktop video software can animate live-action video by downloading NewBlue Cartoonr, the company's fast, easy and free way to give scenes a cartoon look.
Where To Get Broadband Quality Online Videos & Video Podcasts About World Travel For Free
If you are looking to find broadband quality online videos and video pod casts about good holiday destinations and world travel on the internet for free, then please read our free guide below which will save you time searching on the web and will give you some great websites to investigate further.
New Version of VZOchat, a Free High-Speed Video Messenger, is Available for Video Chatting
Join the constantly growing community of more than 220,000 users of VZOchat worldwide at vzochat.com. They all have seen what real video chatting is, and now it is your turn. The VZOchat technology streams video in such a way that even a slow Internet connection can no longer be a problem.
Makeup Mondo - Dedicated Makeup Video Site Launches With Free Professional Celebrity Makeup Video Tips
Makeup Mondo, a Los Angeles based internet video start-up dedicated to innovative video content on makeup, is launching its first round of free how to video tips - clear and easy how to videos deliver a step-by-step guide to red carpet celebrity makeup looks.
Learners Crochet Video - How To Get Free Beginner Crochet Video
An interesting fact I'd like to share with here, in middle French the term croc or croche stands for hook Precise history narration is not as easy task, yet from evidence available as reference some where in 1800s Europe was introduced to crochet
Cut, Sew and Blog - Fashion Designer Malcolm Harris Debut's New Video and Text Blog
Fashion Designer Malcolm Harris of the emerging luxury brand Mal Sirrah announces the September 5th, 2007 debut of his company's daily video and text blog, Cut, Sew and Blog. This launch will coincide with the first day of Mercedes Benz's New York Fashion Week. The Mal Sirrah Spring/Summer 2008 Collection will also be available for viewing on Cut, Sew and Blog.
UK Bingo Site Launches Video Channel and Video Blog
The release looks at how events in the online bingo world have inspired the web master at Playing Bingo to create his own You Tube channel and Video Blog. The video blog is aimed at UK bingo players and encourages them to get involved and post their own Bingo videos.